What’s the difference between test optional and test blind? Do I still need to prep for the SAT/ACT?
Standardized tests like the SAT and ACT remain important for many students, but the goal post has shifted a great deal in the last 18 months. Schools responded to test cancellations last cycle with a huge rush to test optional, resulted in virtually all programs becoming test optional for that cycle. Moreover, some of those schools piloted programs that are set for two or even three years, which leaves a cohort of schools still test optional now. Then, some of the schools that initially announced test optional for Fall 2020 applications are now announcing test optional for Fall 2021. That said, we don’t yet know how many schools will remain test optional next year and over the next few years (or forever). As you start to create your school list, research your schools of interest to see what each has announced (or not yet announced) about testing. Here is an evolving aggregated list, but always check it against the primary source (the school’s web site), as these positions are in flux.
California, by the way, is its own country on this. The University of California Board of Regents initially announced a five-year test optional phase-out period last spring to be followed by no testing or its own testing, but a lawsuit last fall resulting in a temporary injunction that barred consideration of any testing for Fall 2020 applicants. We await the final word on coming cycles. The California State system is separate, and as of today is test blind through the 2023 admissions cycle, that is, test scores will not be considered in admissions.
This is not, however, the majority approach, and test optional does not mean test blind. Even if many schools stay in a test-optional position in the coming years, strong test takers will be at an advantage in admissions at all levels if they can show high scores. The good news is that for students who struggle with testing, this really may become an optional part of the application at many schools. For students who are good at the tests, then, it is a way to stand out. Bottom line: unless you have impediments to testing well, at least put some time into prepping for and taking tests, as competitive scores will help you gain entrance to test-optional institutions and will be required at schools that still make them mandatory. Don’t assume yet that these won’t be a useful component of your application.
Side note: test optional for SAT/ACT and the recent elimination of the SAT subject tests may result in AP courses and scores becoming more important for high-achieving kids. We are seeing some schools (e.g. NYU) move towards a test flexible approach, and it may be that other selective colleges begin to rely on AP tests the way that many UK schools do for US applicants.
CTK pro tip: With the emphasis on STEM education and the ubiquity of screens, my experience is that kids are reading less and show lower literacy proficiency in testing than in the past. Get your kid reading one daily article in the NYT, Economist, Atlantic, WSJ, New Yorker or similar to boost literacy skills. Reading books is wonderful. Doing both is the best!
Do Now: For kids who plan to take the SAT or ACT, they will be ready to prep as soon as they have completed Algebra 2. There is no need to wait for junior year.
Free Presentation: Feb 18, 2021
If you are looking for deeper insight into any of these topics, please register for my free presentation on February 18th through the Maplewood library-- you do NOT need to be a resident/patron to attend. What to Do Now: How to Be Prepared for College Starting in Freshman and Sophomore Years.
